Is it Cheaper to Shop at Aldi or Sam’s Club?
Is Sam’s Club cheaper than Aldi? Ever had that moment in the grocery store where you’re trying to figure out the best place to save some cash? And you’re wondering about the best place to get better deals.
We will go into the comparison of some items between Sam’s Club and Aldi. Forget about the product size because it’s all about the unit price, per ounce, pound, or item.
While exclusively shopping at these stores might cost you more, we’re here to figure out which one gives you the best deals. So, let’s find out the best place to save your money.
Is Sam’s Club Cheaper than Aldi?
We need to compare similar items as much as possible. We also checked store brands in one place and compared them with store brands in the other.
Comparing prices per unit is important too. It challenges the idea that buying in bulk always saves money.
We’ll use a few items to compare Sam’s Club with Aldi to see which areas might be cheaper.
1. Baby Items
Wipes and Formula are cheaper at Sam’s Club, but diapers are more affordable at Aldi.
Now, let’s check out the prices for these baby items at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Item | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aldi | Unit Price |
| Diapers | $34.98 for 234 ct | 14.9 ȼ each | $10.99 for 100 ct | 11 ȼ each |
| Wipes | $17.96 for 1152 ct | 1.6 ȼ each | $3.79 for 216 ct | 1.8 ȼ each |
| Formula | $20.98 for 48 oz | 43.7 ȼ per oz | $13.09 for 23.2 oz | 56.4 ȼ per oz |
2. Baking Items
Aldi is the place to go if you’re into baking and need items like brownie mix, chocolate chips, flour, and sugar. But for other items like extra virgin olive oil, honey, and almond flour, Sam’s Club is way cheaper.
The following baking items and the prices for Sam’s Club and Aldi are;
| Items | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aidi | Unit Price |
| Brownie mix | $7.88 for 80 oz | 9.9 ȼ per oz | $0.85 for 18.3 oz | 4.6 ȼ per oz |
| Chocolate Chips | $9.98 for 72 oz | 13.8 ȼ per or | $1.29 for 12 oz | 10.8 ȼ per oz |
| Flour | $6.98 for 25 lb | 27.9 ȼ per lb | $1.15 for 5 lb | 23 ȼ per lb |
| Sugar | $5.48 for 10 lb | 54.8 ȼ per lb | $1.89 for 4 lb | 47.3 ȼ per oz |
| Extra Virgin Olive oil | $12.48 for 101.4 oz | 12.3 ȼ per oz | $3.89 for 16.9 oz | 23 ȼ per oz |
| Honey | $12.94 for 80 oz | 16.2 ȼ per oz | $5.09 for 24 oz | 21.2 ȼ per oz |
| Almond Flour | $13.44 for 3 lb | $4.48 per lb | $6.19 for 1 lb | $6.19 per lb |
3. Beverages
If you’re into coffee, Aldi is the place to go for cheaper K-cups and ground coffee. On the other hand, Sam’s Club is the best spot for really affordable soft drinks.
Now, let’s check out the prices for these beverages at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Item | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aidi | Unit Price |
| K-Cups | $28.98 for 100 ct | 29 ȼ each | $3.35 for 12 ct | 28 ȼ each |
| Ground Coffee | $24.98 for 40 oz | 62.5ȼ per oz | $3.69 for 12 oz | 30.8 ȼ per oz |
| Soft drinks | $10.88 for 36 cans | 30.2 ȼ per can | $5.18 for 12 cans | 43 ȼ each |
4. Dairy Items
At Aldi, you’ll find dairy items like Almond milk, Sliced cheese, Eggs, Greek Yogurt cups, Milk, Parmesan cheese, and Sour cream at cheaper prices.
For the other items, Sam’s Club is the best place for more affordable Shredded cheese, Block cheese, Butter, and Feta cheese. Now, let’s see the prices for these dairy items at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Items | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aldi | Unit Price |
| Almond milk | $5.48 for 128 oz | 4.3 ȼ per oz | $1.79 for 64 oz | 2.8 ȼ per oz |
| Sliced Cheese | $7.28 for 2 lb | 22.8 ȼ per oz | $1.76 for 8 oz | 21.9 ȼ per oz |
| Shredded Cheese | $12.82 for 5 Ib | 16 ȼ per oz | $2.79 for 12 oz | 23.3 ȼ per oz |
| Block Cheese | $5.53 for 2 Ib | 17.2 ȼ per oz | S1.45 for 8 oz | 18.1 ȼ per oz |
| Eggs | $5.76′ for 3 dozen | $1.92 per dozen | $1.24 for 1 dozen | $1.24 per dozen |
| Greek Yogurt cups | $11.98 for 1653oz cups | 14.1 ȼ per oz | $0.59 for 16.3 oz | 11. ȼ per oz |
| Milk | $3.24 for 1 gallon | $3.24 per gallon | $2.36 for 1 gallon | $2.36 per gallon |
| Parmesan Cheese | $9.78 for 1.5 lb | 40.8 ȼ per oz | $2.16 for 6 oz | 36.8 ȼ per oz |
| Sour cream | $4.42 for 48 oz | 9.2 ȼ per oz | $0.86 for 16 oz | 5.3 ȼ per oz |
| Butter | $7.78 for 4 lb | $1.94 per lb | $2.42 for 1 lb | $2.42 per lb |
| Feta cheese | $7.98 for 1.6 lb | 33.3 ȼ per oz | $52.19 for 4 oz | 54. 8 ȼ per oz |
5. Dry Goods / Canned Goods
When it comes to dry and canned goods, things like Chips and Ritz crackers are cheaper at Sam’s Club. But for the remaining items on the list, Aldi is the place to go for more affordable prices.
Now, let’s check out the prices for these dry and canned items at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Item | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aldi | Unit Price |
| Bread | $3.48 for 40 oz | 8.7 ȼ per oz | $0.95 for 20 oz | 4.8 ȼ per oz |
| Hamburger/ hotdog buns | $2.78 for 16 ct | 17.4 ȼ per bun | $0.79 for 8 ct | 9.9 ȼ per bun |
| Canned black beans | $4.88 for 6 15-oz cans | 7.2 ȼ per oz | $0.48 for 15 oz | 3.2 ȼ per oz |
| Canned green beans | $6.48 for 90 oz | 7.2 ȼ per oz | $0.47 for 14.5 oz | 3.2 ȼ per oz |
| Canned tuna | $11.78 for 40 oz | 29.4 ȼ per oz | $0.65 for 5 oz | 13 ȼ per oz |
| Chips (variety pack) | S12.90 for 50 ct | 25.8 ȼ per bag | $4.79 for 18 ct | 26.6 ȼ per bag |
| Ritz crackers | $8.38 for 61.65 oz | 13.6 ȼ per oz | $1.65 for 11.7 oz | 14.1 ȼ per oz |
| Pasta | $4.98 for 6 1-lb boxes | 5.2 ȼ per oz | S0.75 for 16 oz | 4.7 ȼ per oz |
| Boxed macaroni and cheese | $13.98 for 18 boxes | 77. ȼ ¢ per box | S0.34 for 1 box | 34 ȼ per box |
| Cookies | $8.98 for 52.5 oz | 17.1 ȼ per oz | $1.55 for 15.35 oz | 10.1 ȼ per oz |
| Cheese crackers | $7 98 for 3 lb | 16.6 ȼ per oz | $2.89 for 21 oz | 13.8 ȼ per oz |
| Peanut butter | $9.77 for 96 oz | 10.2 ȼ per oz | $1.19 for 18 oz | 6.6 ȼ per oz |
| Pasta sauce | $6.98 for 3 15-oz Jars | 15.5 ȼ per oz | $1.85 for 24 oz | 7.7 ȼ per oz |
6. Frozen Items
Frozen items are more affordable when compared to Sam’s Club from the list.
Now, let’s see the prices for these frozen items at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Item | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aldi | Unit Price |
| Meatballs | $12.98 for 6 lb | $2.16 per lb | $4.29 for 2 lb | $2.14 per lb |
| Broccoli | $6.48 for 64 oz | 10.1 ȼ per oz | $0.86 for 12 oz | 7.1 ȼ per oz |
| Chicken nuggets | $9.98 for 3 lb | 20.8 ȼ per oz | $3.99 for 25.5 oz | 15.6 ȼ per oz |
| Pizza | $11.98 for 4 18.1-oz pizzas | 16.5 ȼ per oz | $2.19 for 16.4 oz | 14.2 ȼ per oz |
| Potatoes | $4.98 for 4 lb | $1.25 per lb | $1.49 for 2 lb | 75 ȼ per lb |
| Ice Cream | $5.98 for 64 oz | 9.3 ȼ per oz | $1.89 for 48 oz | 3.9 ȼ per oz |
7. Condiments
Balsamic Salad is cheaper at Sam’s Club, but the other items on the list are more affordable at Aldi.
Now, let’s check out the prices for these items at Sam’s Club and Aldi.
| Item | Sam’s Club | Unit Price | Aldi | Unit Price |
| Ketchup | $7.68 for 132 oz | 5.8 ȼ per oz | $0.99 for 38 oz | 2.6ȼ per oz |
| Mayonnaise | $4.68 for 60 oz | 7.8 ȼ per oz | $1.75 for 30 oz | 5.8 ȼ per oz |
| Mustard | $4.28 for 105 oz | 4.1 ȼ per oz | $0.46 for 20 oz | 2.3 ȼ per oz |
| Balsamic Vinaigrette Salad Dressing | $4.96 for 36 oz | 13.8 ȼ per oz | $2.59 for 12 oz | 21.6 ȼ per oz |
Why Does Aldi Offer Items at a Cheap Price?
Most supermarkets stock a lot of well-known brands, but at Aldi, a whopping 90% of what you see is their private label.
By skipping the brand names, Aldi cuts out the middleman, giving you cheaper prices.
Aldi is often cheaper for produce and certain meats compared to pantry items. Their low prices are also pretty consistent, so you save every time you shop there.
While Aldi may be cheaper than Walmart for many items, Walmart often gives discounts, making it a close competition.
When it comes to groceries and household essentials, Sam’s Club usually beats Walmart in terms of price because you get a discount for buying in bulk. However, it doesn’t mean Sam’s Club is always the cheaper option.
Where Do Aldi Products Come From?
In the United States, Aldi gets its products from both within the country and from other nations like China, the United Kingdom, and Germany.
It’s easy to figure out which products are made in the U.S. and which ones are imported.
People like Aldi for different reasons, such as their commitment to low prices, quality products, support for British farmers, and the popular Specialbuys on the Aldi Aisle. Everyone can find their reasons to like Aldi.
When comparing prices with Trader Joe’s, Aldi is quite competitive for popular grocery items. Despite similar prices, each store may have better deals on specific items.
Depending on what you’re looking for, you might find one store consistently more affordable than the other.
In the comparison between Sam’s Club and Aldi, the conclusion is a tie. Sam’s Club offers bulk options and variety, while Aldi stands out for its simplicity, quality, and low prices.
The better choice depends on individual preferences and shopping habits.
