Cornwall is known for its dramatic coastlines, sandy beaches, and surf-ready waves—but two destinations often top every traveler’s list: St Ives and Newquay. These seaside gems each offer their own unique charms, but which is better suited to your next holiday?
This ultimate guide to St Ives or Newquay will help you decide. Whether you’re a couple seeking a romantic getaway, a family after fun activities, or a solo adventurer looking for surf and sunsets, this guide breaks down everything you need to know.
Location and Accessibility
St Ives
St Ives is located in West Cornwall, with its cobbled streets, working harbor, and boutique shops nestled along the coast. It’s more remote than Newquay but still easily accessible by train via a scenic branch line from St Erth.
Newquay
Located on the north coast, Newquay is Cornwall’s surf capital and closer to the A30, making it more accessible by car. Newquay also has Cornwall Airport Newquay, offering domestic flights and some European connections.
Beaches: Surf vs Serenity
Newquay Beaches
Newquay boasts eleven beaches, each with its own personality. Fistral Beach is legendary among surfers worldwide, while Towan Beach offers family-friendly tidal pools and nearby attractions.
Top Beaches in Newquay:
- Fistral Beach (surfing)
- Towan Beach (family-friendly)
- Crantock Beach (scenic and dog-friendly)
St Ives Beaches
St Ives has quieter, scenic beaches ideal for couples, artists, and families. Porthmeor Beach is great for gentle surfing and sunbathing, while Porthminster offers calm, safe waters near top restaurants.
Top Beaches in St Ives:
- Porthmeor Beach (surf & sunsets)
- Porthminster Beach (calm waters)
- Carbis Bay (luxury resort beach)
Accommodation: Budget to Luxury
St Ives
Known for boutique B&Bs and luxury hotels, St Ives offers a refined experience. Many accommodations provide sea views, local artwork, and organic breakfasts.
Top St Ives Options:
- Carbis Bay Hotel (luxury)
- St Ives Harbour Hotel & Spa
- Artist’s Loft Airbnbs
Newquay
Newquay caters to a broader crowd—from surf hostels to four-star resorts. You’ll find more budget-friendly options, particularly suited for group travel and stag/hen parties.
Popular Newquay Stays:
- The Headland Hotel
- Surf N Stay hostels
- Holiday parks and campsites
Things to Do: Culture vs Adventure
St Ives: Arts & Tranquility
St Ives has a rich artistic heritage, home to Tate St Ives and Barbara Hepworth’s sculpture garden. Visitors can enjoy art galleries, pottery studios, and sunset dining.
Things to Do in St Ives:
- Visit Tate St Ives
- St Ives Boat Trips (seal watching)
- Art workshops and gallery tours
Newquay: Surf & Nightlife
Newquay thrives on adrenaline. You’ll find water sports, coasteering, zip-lining, and lively nightclubs. Families also love Newquay Zoo and Blue Reef Aquarium.
Things to Do in Newquay:
- Learn to surf at Fistral Beach
- Explore Newquay Zoo
- Party on the Newquay Strip
Food Scene: Gourmet vs Grab-and-Go
St Ives
St Ives prides itself on its fine dining and artisan cafés. Think seafood caught that morning, paired with wine on a terrace as the sun sets over the sea.
Top Eateries in St Ives:
- The Seafood Café
- Porthminster Beach Café
- Blas Burgerworks
Newquay
Newquay is great for casual diners. From fish and chips to beachside BBQs and vegan cafés, there’s something for every palate.
Top Eateries in Newquay:
- The Fish House at Fistral
- Bush Pepper (Australian fusion)
- The Boathouse street food market
Best for Families?
- Newquay wins for families with teenagers and young children thanks to its variety of kid-friendly attractions, surf schools, and fun parks.
- St Ives is ideal for families looking for calmer holidays, art experiences, and beach relaxation.
Nightlife: Laid-Back vs Lively
- Newquay offers clubs, live music bars, and pub crawls for those seeking excitement after dark.
- St Ives provides a quieter nightlife with wine bars, harbour-front pubs, and occasional live jazz sessions.
Budget: Where’s Cheaper?
|
Category |
St Ives |
Newquay |
|
Hotels |
$$$ (higher) |
$$ (mid-range) |
|
Food |
$$$ |
$-$$ |
|
Attractions |
$$ |
$$ |
|
Parking |
Difficult |
Easier & Cheaper |
While both can be expensive in peak season, Newquay tends to offer better value across accommodation, dining, and family attractions.
St Ives vs Newquay: Final Verdict
|
Category |
Winner |
|
Best for Surfers |
Newquay |
|
Best for Art Lovers |
St Ives |
|
Best for Families |
Newquay |
|
Best for Couples |
St Ives |
|
Best for Budget Travel |
Newquay |
|
Best for Foodies |
St Ives |
Insider Tips for Visiting Both
- Avoid peak months (July–August) if you’re after peace and better prices.
- Book accommodations early—both towns fill up fast!
- Try both! Stay in one and day-trip to the other. It’s only an hour’s drive apart.
Read Also: Hidden Gems in Cornwall You Shouldn’t Miss
Conclusion
Whether you choose the artistic charm of St Ives or the energetic vibe of Newquay, one thing is certain: Cornwall offers some of the UK’s most breathtaking and diverse coastal experiences. Use this guide to match your travel style and budget, and you’ll be well on your way to planning a truly unforgettable trip.
Leave a Reply